select c.id,c.cargoinfo_id,c.cargociq_id, (select ciqcode from Import_cargociq where id=c.cargociq_id) cargociq, a.cargoinfo_id,a.cargociq_id, (select ciqcode from Import_cargociq where id=a.cargociq_id) appciq from import_cargo c left join Import_appstate s on s.cargo_id=c.id left join Import_approval a on a.id=s.app_id left join import_main m on m.contractno=c.contractno where c.cargociq_id<>a.cargociq_id